• Dutch
  • Frisian
  • Saterfrisian
  • Afrikaans
Show all
31.3.2.Supplementive use
quickinfo

Section 28.3 has shown that there are two types of supplementives that can be distinguished by their position relative to adverbials such as altijdalways and vaakoften: supplementive-I precedes these adverbial phrases, while supplementive-II follows them. Furthermore, the semantic relation that these supplementive types have with the remainder of the clause is different: supplementive-I triggers a conditional relation in which it acts as the antecedent (the if-part) and the clause as the consequent (the then-part); supplementive-II can give rise to a simultaneity reading or a conditional relation in which it acts as the consequent and the clause as the antecedent. The following subsections will show that both present and past/passive participles can be used in the two supplementive functions.

readmore
[+]  I.  Present participles

Present participles can be used as supplementive-I and as supplementive-II, as shown in (148). Note, however, that in (148b) only the simultaneity reading is possible; the conditional reading associated with supplementive-II (Whenever Jan is in the library, he works) is not available. Instead, the example is habitual (Jan always works).

148
a. Jan zit werkend altijd in de bibliotheek.
supplementive-I
  Jan sits working always in the library
  'Whenever Jan works, he is in the library.'
b. Jan zit altijd werkend in de bibliotheek.
supplementive-II
  Jan sits always working in the library
  'Jan is always working in the library.'

The present participle in (148a) expresses durative aspect and can therefore be considered to be verbal; in this respect, it differs from its complementive counterpart, which is truly adjectival. This categorial difference explains why intransitive, transitive, and unaccusative present participles can be used as supplementives, but not as complementives (cf. Table 7 in Section 31.3.1, sub II). Some examples are given in (149).

149
a. Lachend liep Jan de kamer in.
intransitive
  laughing walked Jan the room into
  'Jan walked into the room while laughing.'
b. Zingend ging Jan naar zijn werk.
transitive
  singing went Jan to his work
  'Jan went to his work while singing.'
c. Stervend schreef hij zijn testament.
unaccusative
  dying wrote he his will
  'He wrote his will while dying.'

Haeseryn et al. (1997) has observed that the durative meaning of an activity-denoting present participle can be emphasized by placing the word al in front of it. Another result of adding this element seems to be that the present participle must refer to a continuous, uninterrupted action. This is very clear from example (150), taken from Jansen and Lentz (2002), which is typically found in recipes.

150
Voeg de room al roerend(e) aan de soep toe.
  Add the cream al stirring to the soup prt.
'Add the cream to the soup while continuously stirring it.'

The construction with al has not been studied extensively, but it seems to behave differently from the present participle constructions in (149) in several ways. First, in the construction with al, the present participle can optionally be followed by an -e ending, which would lead to a highly marked result with the present participles in (149); at best, these examples would be judged as archaic. Second, the examples in (151) show that the al + participle construction can never be preceded by the direct object of the participle, while this seems possible in the absence of al. This is also clear from example (150), where the direct object of the transitive verb roerento stir is left implicit: it is the syntactic context (here: the presence of the aan-PP) that makes it clear that it is the soup that is being stirred.

151
a. ? Jan kwam een vrolijk deuntje fluitend binnen.
  Jan came a merry tune whistling inside
  'Jan entered while whistling a tune.'
b. Jan kwam al (*een deuntje) fluitende binnen.

Similarly, the examples in (152a&b) show that the construction with al cannot be accompanied by a PP-complement, while this is easily possible in the absence of al. Note, however, that the result with al seems to improve slightly when the PP-complement follows the present participle.

152
a. Op alles en iedereen scheldend verliet Jan de kamer.
  against everything and everyone fulminating left Jan the room
  'Jan left the room while fulminating against all and everything.'
b. * Al op alles en iedereen scheldende verliet Jan de kamer.
b'. ?? Al scheldende op alles en iedereen verliet Jan de kamer.

Finally, the examples in (153) show that these co-occurrence restrictions do not only apply to arguments of the verb, but also seem to apply to adverbial modifiers; while present participles can normally be preceded by e.g. manner adverbs, this produces a degraded result in the al + participle construction.

153
a. Jan kwam vrolijk fluitend binnen.
  Jan came merrily whistling inside
  'Jan entered while merrily whistling.'
b. Jan kwam al (??vrolijk) fluitende binnen.

The restrictions on the al + participle construction suggest that the present participle has lost at least some of its verbal properties. For lack of information, we will not dwell on the question regarding the categorial status of the present participle and leave it to future research.

[+]  II.  Past/passive participles

The examples in (154) show that past/passive participles behave more or less the same way as present participles: they can be used both as supplementive-I and as supplementive-II, although the latter only expresses the simultaneity reading, as is clear from the fact that (154b) simply expresses that Emil is often punished.

154
a. Emil moet bestraft vaak in de schuur zitten.
supplementive-I
  Emil must punished often in the barn sit
  'When he is punished, Emil must often go into the barn.'
b. Emil moet vaak bestraft in de schuur zitten.
supplementive-II
  Emil must often punished in the barn sit
  'Often, Emil must go into the barn as punishment.'
[+]  III.  Modal infinitives

We have not been able to construct examples in which modal infinitives are used in either of the two supplementive functions.

References:
    report errorprintcite