• Dutch
  • Frisian
  • Saterfrisian
  • Afrikaans
Show all
19.1.5.3.The syntactic distribution of (noun phrases containing) geen
quickinfo

This section concludes the discussion of geen by briefly discussing the syntactic distribution of noun phrases containing geen. It also discusses the independent uses of geen, i.e. cases in which it is not part of a noun phrase.

readmore
[+]  I.  Distribution of noun phrases quantified by geen

This subsection discusses the syntactic distribution of noun phrases with geen. We will consider whether they occur as arguments (subject, direct object, indirect object, complement of a preposition), as predicates, or as adjuncts.

[+]  A.  Distribution as argument

A noun phrase quantified by geen has a somewhat limited distribution when geen has its core meaning of negative quantifier. It can appear as the subject of an expletive construction, and it can also be used as a direct object, but not as an indirect object; the (c)-examples in (309) are rather awkward.

309
a. Er zijn geen eieren meer.
  there are no eggs anymore
  'We are out of eggs.'
b. We hebben nog geen nieuwe eieren gekocht.
  we have yet no new eggs bought
  'We didnʼt buy any new eggs yet.'
c. ?? Ik heb geen studenten mijn boek geleend.
  I have no students my books lent
c'. * Ik heb mijn boek aan geen studenten geleend.
  I have my books to no students lent

The unacceptability (309c') may also be due to the fact that using a noun phrase with geen as the complement of a preposition generally leads to an unacceptable result: the negation must be expressed by the negative adverb niet.

310
a. Ik hou niet van bloemencorso’s.
  I love not of flower.shows
  'I donʼt like flower shows.'
b. * Ik hou van geen bloemencorso’s.
  I love of no flower.shows

For the more special meanings of geen, the restrictions seem to be lifted. This is illustrated by the examples in (311) for noun phrases expressing the “not a single” reading. These examples show that such noun phrases need not occur in the expletive construction, can easily occur as indirect objects, and can even be used as the complement of a preposition.

311
a. Geen (enkel) huis was meer te koop.
  no single house was anymore for sale
b. Ze hebben nog geen (enkel) huis gezien.
  they have yet no single house seen
c. Ik heb geen (enkele) student een boek geleend.
  I have no single student a book lent
d. Ze willen in geen (enkel) huis wonen.
  they want in no single house live

Haeseryn et al. (1997:1657) notes that geen-phrases can also occur as the complement of a preposition in certain idiomatic constructions. These all involve a more or less emphatic negation. Some examples, taken from Klooster (2001b), are given in (312).

312
a. Hij is in geen velden of wegen te zien.
  he is in no fields or roads to see
  'He is nowhere to be seen.'
b. Dit is voor geen mens te begrijpen.
  this is for no person to understand
  'This is completely unintelligible.'
c. Die ellende valt met geen pen te beschrijven.
  that misery falls with no pen to describe
  'That misery is incredible/is impossible to describe.'
[+]  B.  Distribution as predicate

A geen phrase can be used as a nominal predicate if it is used with its core reading. This is illustrated in (313) with examples of copular and vinden constructions. We have not been able to find or construct examples of geen phrases with a “not a single” reading.

313
a. Jan is echt geen aansteller.
  Jan is really no poser
  'Jan is truly not a poser.'
b. Ik vind Jan echt geen aansteller.
  I consider Jan really no poser
  'I truly donʼt consider Jan a poser.'

Geen phrases in non-negative questions, discussed in Section 19.1.5.1, sub IIIE, are restricted to the function of predicate. Some examples are given in (314).

314
a. Is Jan geen aansteller?
  is Jan no poser
  'Isnʼt Jan a poser?'
b. Vind je Jan geen aansteller?
  consider you Jan no poser
  'Donʼt you consider Jan to be a poser?'
[+]  C.  Distribution as adjunct

The degree reading of geen in (282), in which geen is construed with a numeral following it and means something like “less than”, is particularly common in adverbial phrases. Example (282a) is repeated here as (315a). Example (315b) shows that geen phrases can also easily be used as nominal adjuncts in their “not a single” reading. In these constructions, the main accent falls on the element immediately following geen, i.e. the numeral in (315a) and the head noun in (315b). Geen phrases in which geen receives prosodic prominence are difficult to construe as adjuncts.

315
a. Na nog geen tien minuten brak de hel los.
  after yet no ten minutes broke the hell loose
  'After less than ten minutes, all hell broke loose.'
b. Ik had er geen seconde over nagedacht.
  I had there no second about prt.-thought
  'I had not thought about it for a (single) second.'
[+]  II.  Distribution of geen as an independent constituent

This subsection is concerned with the use of geen external to the noun phrase, i.e. we now turn to an examination of its use as an independent syntactic constituent (argument, predicate, and adjunct), as well as its use as floating quantifier.

[+]  A.  Distribution as argument

Geen does not easily occur independently in argument positions. However, example (316a) shows that there is a contrast between cases with singular and plural agreement, in that the former are better than the latter. In order to express the intended meaning, Dutch can resort to two strategies: one is to add the numeral éénone or enkelesingle to the right of geen, as in (316b); the other is to use a partitive construction, as in (316c). In both cases, the agreement between the subject and the finite verb is necessarily singular.

316
Discourse topic: applicants for a job
a. Geen ?komt/*komen in aanmerking voor de baan.
  no comes/come in consideration for the job
  'None is eligible for the job.'
b. Geen één/enkele komt in aanmerking voor de baan.
  no one/single comes in consideration for the job
  'Not a single one is eligible for the job.'
c. Geen van hen komt in aanmerking voor de baan.
  none (of them) comes in consideration for the job
  'None (of them) is eligible for the job.'
[+]  B.  Distribution as predicate and adjunct

In present-day Dutch, geen cannot be used as a predicate (which was possible in earlier stages of the language): examples such as (317a) are unacceptable. Note that (317b) is not a counterexample; this example involves quantitative er, which is associated with the interpretive gap within a noun phrase containing geen. Since adjuncts are also predicates, the impossibility of example (317a) automatically precludes adjunct construal of geen.

317
a. * Dit is geen.
  this is none
b. Dit is er [geen [e]].
  this is er no
[+]  C.  Distribution as floating quantifier

Example (318a) shows that neither geen nor geen één/enkele can be used as a floating quantifier. However, the partitive noun phrase geen van alle/beide in (318b) can be used in this way. As usual, the floating quantifier must follow its associate, as in (318b), unless it is moved into the clause-initial position, as in (318b'). If the associate has a human reference, as in (319), Dutch orthography requires a plural ending -n on the quantifier.

318
a. * Ik heb ze nog geen (één/enkele) gelezen. [Discourse topic: books]
  I have them yet no one/single read
b. Ik heb ze geen van alle/beide gelezen.
  I have them none of all/both read
b'. Geen van alle/beide heb ik ze gelezen.
319
a. * Ik heb ze nog geen (één/enkele) ontmoet.
Discourse topic: people
  I have them yet no one/single met
b. Ik heb ze nog geen van allen/beiden ontmoet.
  I have them yet none of all/both met
b'. Geen van allen/beiden heb ik ze ontmoet.

Similarly, geen can be used as a floating quantifier in partitive constructions with numerals (Paardekooper 1986:472). The numerals in these constructions always take the ending -en in written language, regardless of the kind of entity being referred to. This is illustrated in (320).

320
a. Ik heb ze nog geen van tweeën gelezen.
  I have them yet none of two read
b. Ik heb ze nog geen van drieën gezien.
  I have them yet none of three seen
References:
    report errorprintcite